- If Sarah Lee made ice cream, how would it be made? Fussily, with milk, cream, golden egg yolks, only the finest natural ingredients. Well, Sarah Lee ice cream is here. Take strawberries, Sarah Lee makes it with real strawberries, the plumpest, sweetest, juiciest around and the name, Sarah Lee Old Fashioned Ice Cream, because it's rich, creamy, the way ice cream used to be. Sarah Lee Old Fashioned Ice Cream, just what you'd expect from Sara Lee.